Case study 04 / Government / Justice
Finding a better answer to juror expenses.
Testing the proposed digital solution, then focusing on the need that research actually found.
The challenge
HMCTS wanted to test whether moving juror expenses and loss-of-earnings claims online would help jurors and court staff. The service processed around 200,000 claims a year.
What we did
The team visited courts, interviewed jurors, observed processing officers and walked through the existing paper process. It tested the proposed digital route against the real effort of recording and submitting claims at court.
The outcome
Research did not support an online claims service: paper worked for many jurors, while uploading receipts could add barriers and cost. The team identified a stronger need for clearer information on what jurors could claim. HMCTS took the recommendations into alpha, and a calculator was developed for GOV.UK.
What this shows
Good discovery can stop an unnecessary digital project and focus investment on the real need.